Debt Review vs a Debt Consolidation Loan: Which Is Better?
Short answer: It depends on your situation. A debt consolidation loan suits people who still have a good credit record and can afford the new payment. Debt review suits people who are already over-indebted and struggling to pay. It restructures your debt into one lower payment and gives legal protection, but you can't take new credit until you finish.
What is a debt consolidation loan?
A debt consolidation loan is a new loan that you use to pay off several existing debts. Instead of paying five creditors, you pay one lender.
The monthly payment can be lower if the new loan has a lower interest rate or a longer term. But it's still a loan. You have to apply, pass a credit check and show that you can afford it.
Some consolidation loans are secured against your home. This can mean a lower rate, but your home is at risk if you can't keep up.
What is debt review?
Debt review is a legal process under the National Credit Act. It is for people who are over-indebted, meaning they can't afford all their debt payments.
A registered debt counsellor works out what you can afford and negotiates with your creditors on your behalf. The new plan is made legally binding by a court or the National Consumer Tribunal. You make one monthly payment, which is shared between your creditors. While you follow the plan, creditors can't take legal action on the included debts.
Debt review doesn't give you new money. It changes the terms of the debt you already have.
How do they compare?
| Debt consolidation loan | Debt review | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A new loan to pay off old debts | A legal process that restructures existing debts |
| Who it suits | People with a good credit record who can still afford their debt | People who are over-indebted and struggling to pay |
| Credit check needed? | Yes | No new credit is given, but you must be over-indebted to qualify |
| Monthly payment | One payment to one lender | One payment to a payment distribution agency |
| Lower interest? | Only if the new loan's rate is lower | The counsellor may negotiate lower rates, but creditors don't always agree |
| Legal protection | None | Creditors can't take legal action on included debts while you keep to the plan |
| New credit | Allowed | Not allowed until you finish |
| Effect on credit record | A new account and a credit enquiry | A debt review flag until you get a clearance certificate |
Not sure which route fits your situation?
See if you qualify for lowered debt paymentsA few quick questions, no obligation. Every situation is different, so results are not guaranteed.
When does a consolidation loan make sense?
A consolidation loan can be a good choice if:
- Your credit record is still in good shape.
- The new loan has a lower interest rate than your current debts.
- You can comfortably afford the new monthly payment.
- You are confident you won't run up the old accounts again.
The biggest risk is that people pay off their cards and store accounts, then slowly use them again. Within a year or two, they have the consolidation loan and new debt on top of it.
When does debt review make more sense?
Debt review may be the better fit if:
- You have already been turned down for a consolidation loan.
- You are missing payments or only paying minimums.
- Creditors are calling, or you have received a letter of demand.
- Your debt payments leave you short for food, transport or school costs.
- You want a fixed plan and legal protection while you pay off your debt.
The trade-off is that you can't take new credit while under debt review. For many people, that's exactly the break they need.
Can I take a consolidation loan while under debt review?
No. While you're under debt review, you can't take out any new credit, including a consolidation loan. If someone offers you a loan to "get you out of debt review", be very careful. Leaving debt review after a court order is a legal process, and offers like this are often costly or not what they seem.
Key takeaways
- A consolidation loan is new credit. Debt review restructures the debt you already have.
- Consolidation suits people with a good credit record who can still afford their payments.
- Debt review suits people who are over-indebted, and it comes with legal protection.
- You can't take new credit, including consolidation loans, while under debt review.
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheaper, debt review or a consolidation loan?
It depends on the interest rates, fees and how long you take to pay. A consolidation loan with a much lower rate can be cheaper. Debt review can lower your monthly payment, but it may take longer to repay. Compare the total cost, not just the monthly amount.
Why was I turned down for a consolidation loan?
Lenders must check that you can afford new credit. If you are already over-indebted or have missed payments, they may decline your application. Debt review was created for people in this situation.
Does a consolidation loan affect my credit record?
Yes. Applying adds a credit enquiry, and the new loan appears as a new account. If you pay on time, it can help your record over time. If you miss payments, it will hurt it.
Is debt review only for people with very large debts?
No. Debt review is about whether you can afford your payments, not just how much you owe. Someone with a modest income and moderate debt can still be over-indebted.
Find out if you qualify for lower debt payments through debt review.
See if you qualify for lowered debt paymentsA few quick questions, no obligation. Every situation is different, so results are not guaranteed.
